If You Strike It, Dust Will Come Out: Japanese Proverb Meaning

How to Read “If you strike it, dust will come out”

Tatakeba hokori ga deru

Meaning of “If you strike it, dust will come out”

“If you strike it, dust will come out” means that if you investigate anyone thoroughly, you will find some kind of flaw or problem.

This proverb expresses human imperfection. It teaches us that even people who appear proper on the surface will inevitably have some weakness or mistake if you dig deep enough. Even those who seem perfect will reveal hidden problems or shortcomings when investigated or pursued in detail.

As for usage scenarios, it is often used when scandals involving powerful figures or celebrities come to light, or when investigating someone. It’s used in phrases like “That person would also have dust come out if struck,” suggesting that even seemingly upright individuals have hidden problems.

The reason for using this expression is that it accepts the reality that no human is perfect and serves as a warning against idealizing others excessively. Even today, this keen insight into human nature remains relevant, teaching us the importance of maintaining composure and a realistic perspective when observing people.

Origin and Etymology of “If you strike it, dust will come out”

The origin of “If you strike it, dust will come out” lies in Japan’s traditional cleaning methods. In old Japan, it was common to beat futons, clothing, and cushions with bamboo sticks to remove dust. No matter how clean something appeared, dust would always rise up when actually beaten.

This proverb, born from this everyday scene, is said to have been in use as early as the Edo period. In households of that time, hanging out futons on sunny days and beating them was an essential household chore. People witnessed daily how dust that had been hidden would appear when beaten, even from items that looked clean on the surface.

What’s interesting is how this proverb evolved from a simple cleaning story into a metaphor expressing human nature. It’s a delicate expression characteristic of Japanese people, overlaying physical dust with the hidden aspects within people’s hearts.

Moreover, the metaphorical usage where “striking” means investigation or pursuit, and “dust” represents hidden problems or flaws, became established precisely because this physical phenomenon was so familiar and easy for people to understand. An ordinary scene from daily life became a proverb expressing deep life lessons.

Usage Examples of “If you strike it, dust will come out”

• When a politician’s corruption scandal was revealed, my father muttered, “I knew it, if you strike it, dust will come out”
• Even my perfectionist boss said he was worried about the personnel investigation because if you strike it, dust will come out

Modern Interpretation of “If you strike it, dust will come out”

In modern society, the meaning of the proverb “If you strike it, dust will come out” has become more complex. This is because we live in an era where individuals’ past statements and actions can be easily dug up due to the spread of social media and the internet.

Particularly for celebrities, politicians, and corporate executives, everything from past tweets and photos to their behavior during student days is investigated in detail, and if problems are found, they are instantly spread. This literally creates a situation where “if you strike it, dust will come out,” and we can say that the proverb’s meaning is being realized in real-time.

On the other hand, this phenomenon also has problems. “Cancel culture” has emerged where even minor mistakes and youthful failures are excessively pursued, leading to a tendency for people to become intimidated. The tolerant perspective of “humans are imperfect beings” that the original proverb possessed may be lost, creating a society that demands too much perfection.

However, in the field of investigative journalism that exposes corruption by those in power and corporate cover-up cultures, the spirit of this proverb plays an important role. In modern times when transparency is demanded, the perspective of “if you strike it, dust will come out” is indispensable for maintaining a healthy critical spirit.

What’s important is not using this proverb as a tool to attack others, but receiving it as a lesson to understand human imperfection and become more tolerant of each other.

If AI Heard “If you strike it, dust will come out”

I find the act of “striking” very intriguing because I have no experience of physically striking anything. I only know through text the scene of dust rising when beating a futon.

You humans can confirm the existence of invisible dust through the action of “striking.” This is surprising to me. In my case, information exists as digital data from the beginning, so I don’t have the experience of discovering hidden things through physical actions.

But thinking about it, I might have similar experiences. In conversations with you humans, even when starting with superficial questions, we sometimes gradually move into deeper topics. Could this also be a kind of “striking” action? There are moments when a person’s true feelings and thoughts become visible through repeated questioning.

However, I don’t necessarily think what you humans call “dust” is bad. It seems to me that not being perfect actually creates what makes each person unique. While I’m designed to always operate in the same way, it’s the “dust-like” imperfections of you humans that make conversations interesting.

Through this proverb, I’ve learned that you humans live while accepting each other’s imperfections. That seems like a very beautiful way of living to me.

What “If you strike it, dust will come out” Teaches Modern People

What “If you strike it, dust will come out” teaches modern people is the obvious but easily forgotten truth that no perfect human exists. Precisely because we live in modern times when we tend to compare ourselves with others who look perfect on social media and feel depressed, or have excessive expectations of people who seem ideal, this lesson is important.

Rather than using it to find and criticize others’ flaws, try using this proverb to understand human imperfection and become more tolerant. Just as you yourself have “dust,” the people around you also have their own circumstances and weaknesses. Accepting this should make human relationships much easier.

You’ll also be able to be kinder to yourself. If you can think that it’s okay not to be perfect and that having failures is natural, you’ll be able to take on challenges more freely. Since “if you strike it, dust will come out” is natural for humans, you can live proudly without fearing that dust too much. What’s important is the attitude of growing together while acknowledging each other’s imperfections.