How to Read “A samurai has his own set principles”
shi ni ichijō no ron ari
Meaning of “A samurai has his own set principles”
“A samurai has his own set principles” means that educated people and intellectuals each have their own consistent theories and beliefs.
True scholars and experts don’t just possess knowledge. They develop their own views through years of research and deep thinking.
This proverb is used when appreciating expertise and originality in academic fields.
For example, when you see a researcher presenting unique theories, you might say “As expected, a samurai has his own set principles.”
It’s also used to show understanding when experts hold different views. This is natural and expected.
In modern times, this saying offers insight into what makes a true expert.
In an age overflowing with information, it teaches the value of having consistent personal views. This matters more than simply collecting random facts.
Origin and Etymology
Clear historical records about this proverb’s origin are limited. However, the structure of the phrase reveals interesting background.
The word “shi” (samurai) came to Japan from ancient China. It originally referred to the educated class who studied academics or martial arts.
In Japan, especially during the Edo period, “shi” described samurai who valued learning. They deeply studied fields like Confucianism and military strategy.
The phrase “ichijō no ron” (set principles) means more than just opinions.
It refers to systematic theories established through years of academic pursuit. “Ichijō” carries the meaning of “consistent” or “firm.”
It points to views based on deep thought, not casual ideas.
This proverb likely emerged from values in Japan’s intellectual society. Scholars were expected to develop their own philosophical systems.
Simply accumulating knowledge wasn’t enough. Integrating it into unique views was the mark of a true scholar.
The saying probably arose from Edo period culture, where samurai spirit and scholarship were closely connected.
Usage Examples
- He shows that a samurai has his own set principles in economics, maintaining his unique market theory for over 20 years
- That teacher demonstrates that a samurai has his own set principles, sticking to his educational philosophy without following trendy theories
Universal Wisdom
“A samurai has his own set principles” beautifully captures the essence of human intellectual activity.
Why do people keep learning and thinking? Not simply to collect knowledge. We have a deep desire to create our own framework for understanding the world.
Humans have an instinctive wish to integrate scattered information and build a consistent worldview.
This relates to what psychology calls “the need for cognitive consistency.” We dislike contradiction and confusion. We want to understand things in a coherent way.
When true scholars develop unique theories, they’re expressing this fundamental human nature.
This proverb also suggests the value of diversity. Each scholar having their own “set principles” means no single absolute truth exists.
We can view the world from various perspectives. This is the source of richness in human society.
Our ancestors understood that true intelligence isn’t about copying others’ opinions.
It’s about having unique views reached through your own deep thinking. This insight holds even deeper meaning in our information-flooded modern age.
When AI Hears This
When ten experts produce ten different opinions, cognitive science reveals an interesting structure.
The Dunning-Kruger effect shows that people with little knowledge become overconfident. But experts with more knowledge develop different blind spots.
Beginners “don’t know what they don’t know.” Experts tend to “assume what they know is everything.”
In medicine, surgeons believe surgery can cure problems. Physicians argue that medicine is the answer.
Both are correct, but they view problems through their specialty filters. This creates different solutions.
This isn’t lack of knowledge. It’s cognitive distortion created by deep expertise. The brain seeks processing efficiency by interpreting things through familiar patterns.
More interesting is how confidence in “one’s own principles” grows with expertise.
Years of experience and success reinforce these thinking patterns. In other words, being an expert can paradoxically reduce flexibility.
When experts clash intensely on social media, we’re witnessing “a samurai has his own set principles” replayed in modern times.
Lessons for Today
This proverb teaches us the importance of becoming thinking subjects, not just information consumers.
We can access infinite information online today. This makes it crucial to digest, integrate, and form unique views from what we learn.
When you study something, don’t just collect knowledge. Keep asking yourself, “How do I think about this problem?”
You don’t need to be an expert. Through your experiences and learning, you can develop consistent ways of thinking about things.
This becomes your life compass. It provides judgment criteria when you feel lost.
At the same time, this proverb teaches respect for others’ “set principles.”
Everyone having different perspectives is natural. This diversity enriches society.
Hold your own views while listening to others’ different opinions. This balance of intellectual humility and confidence is the ideal this proverb shows us.
Comments