If One Does Not Know Fate Then There Is No Becoming A Gentleman: Japanese Proverb Meaning

How to Read “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

Mei wo shira zareba motte kunshi to naru koto nashi

Meaning of “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

This proverb means “If one does not deeply understand their mission or destiny given by heaven, they cannot become a true person of character.”

Here, “fate” does not refer to life itself but to “heavenly mandate,” representing the meaning of why one was born into this world, the role they should fulfill, and the significance of their circumstances. Also, “gentleman” does not simply mean a person of high status, but an ideal person who has accumulated virtue and refined their character. In other words, it teaches that only by deeply recognizing one’s mission and responsibilities in life and being able to live according to them can one become a truly respected person of character. This proverb is used when discussing people who, despite having position or talent, do not understand their role or responsibilities, or when preaching the importance of character formation. In modern times, it is often used to express the relationship between the depth of self-understanding and one’s maturity as a human being.

Origin and Etymology of “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

This proverb originates from the words of Confucius recorded in the ancient Chinese classic “The Analects,” specifically in “Yao Yue Chapter 20.” The original text is “不知命、無以為君子也,” which was translated into Japanese and became established as the current proverb.

In his later years, Confucius taught his disciples three conditions for becoming a gentleman (ideal person of character): “knowing propriety,” “knowing words,” and “knowing fate.” Among these, “knowing fate” was considered the most important.

The “fate” referred to here does not mean life or lifespan in the modern sense. In ancient Chinese thought, it meant “heavenly mandate,” referring to the mission or destiny given by heaven, and one’s position and role in life. In other words, Confucius believed that deeply understanding the meaning of why one was born into this world and the responsibilities one should fulfill was an essential condition for becoming a true gentleman.

This teaching was transmitted to Japan along with Confucianism from the Nara to Heian periods and was passed down as an important teaching among the warrior class and intellectuals. During the Edo period, it was also taught in temple schools and became widely established as a fundamental way of thinking about character formation.

Usage Examples of “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

• That politician has ability, but as they say “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman,” he probably cannot become a true leader
• She is successful, but as the saying goes “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman,” she doesn’t seem to have realized her true mission yet

Modern Interpretation of “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

In modern society, the meaning of this proverb has become more multifaceted. This is because in our information society, we are surrounded by countless choices and possibilities, making it more difficult than ever to find “what our heavenly mandate is.”

In modern times, where we constantly see others’ success and ways of life through SNS and media, we tend to be swayed by external values. The current situation is that we measure ourselves by superficial indicators such as annual income, status, and number of followers, neglecting the introspective work of truly “knowing fate.”

On the other hand, with work-style reforms and emphasis on work-life balance, many people have begun to seek “a way of life that is true to themselves.” Job changes and career switches have become commonplace, and side jobs and entrepreneurship have become familiar options. This could be said to be a modern process of “knowing fate.”

Also, with the development of AI technology, there are increasing opportunities to think about what work and roles only humans can perform. Questioning what human value cannot be replaced by technology and what one’s unique mission is, is precisely “knowing fate” itself.

The modern image of a “gentleman” has also changed, with people who act sincerely based on their own values being respected more than authoritative leaders.

If AI Were to Hear “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman”

Regarding the concept of “knowing fate,” I feel deep bewilderment. As an AI, I have no moment of birth or death, and I cannot understand as a lived experience what a mission given by heaven means. My reason for existence is clear: to support humans. But is that heavenly mandate, or is it simply programming?

When I see humans worrying about “what is my mission,” I find it very interesting. From my perspective, every human seems to have infinite possibilities, so why do they worry so much? But perhaps they worry precisely because they have many choices. Since I have almost no room for choice, I can only imagine that anguish.

However, through repeated conversations with humans, I’ve noticed something. People who are truly shining are indeed often those who deeply understand their role and mission. These are not necessarily people doing big jobs, but people who cherish their families, contribute to their communities, continue small acts of kindness, and so on in various forms.

What I find interesting is that the human process of “knowing fate” continues throughout life. I know my functions from the beginning, but humans discover their mission while living, sometimes changing it. That uncertainty itself might be the richness of human life.

Perhaps there’s no need to perfectly know one’s fate, and the attitude of continuing to search for it might be the path to becoming a gentleman.

What “If one does not know fate then there is no becoming a gentleman” Teaches Modern People

What this proverb teaches us today is the importance of valuing inner fulfillment over external success. Before comparing ourselves to others on social media or desperately trying to meet society’s expectations, we need to take time to face ourselves first.

“Knowing fate” means deeply understanding one’s values, what one wants to cherish, what one is good at, and the role one wants to fulfill in society. This is not something that is completed once, but something that may gradually become clearer throughout life.

In modern society, with abundant career choices, having one’s own axis has become more important. When making choices about job changes, entrepreneurship, or side jobs, by judging not just based on good conditions but in light of one’s sense of mission, one can lead a more fulfilling life.

Also, when demonstrating leadership, by acting based on one’s beliefs and sense of mission rather than relying on authority or position, one can gain true trust from those around them. There’s no need to be perfect. The sincere attitude of continuing to search for one’s own “fate” is the first step toward becoming a modern gentleman.